Everybody's Comet: A Layman's Guide to Comet Hale-Bopp
by Alan Hale
High-Lonesome Books, 1996
softcover, 162 pp., illus.
ISBN 0-944383-38-6
US$12.95
The Comet Hale-Bopp Book
by Thomas Hockey
ATL Press Scientific Publishers, 1996
softcover, 175 pp., illus.
ISBN 1-882360-15-X
US$19.95
An Observer's Guide to Comet Hale-Bopp
by Don Machholz
MakeWood Products, 1996
softcover, 82 pp., illus.
ISBN 0-9646487-2-5
US$12.00
Comet of the Century: From Halley to Hale-Bopp
by Fred Schaaf
Copernicus/Springer-Verlag, 1997
hardcover, 384 pp., illus.
ISBN 0-387-94793-0
US$29.00
It's no surprise a number of books have been published about Hale-Bopp. The comet was discovered in the summer of 1995, giving writers and publishers plenty of lead time to publish several books on the comet. The belief that the comet would be a great, bright comet, held by some since its discovery beyond the orbit of Jupiter, no doubt fueled more interest in the comet and books on the comet. The four books reviewed here run the gamut from introductory pieces for those who know nothing about comets to observing guides to a study on comets in general.
Two books, The Comet Hale-Bopp Book by Thomas Hockey, an astronomy professor at the University of Northern Iowa, and Everybody's Comet by comet co-discoverer Alan Hale, are oriented as general guides to the comet for those who know little, if anything, about comets. Although the books are about the same size, they cover their subject matter somewhat differently. Despite the title The Comet Hale-Bopp Book, Hockey's text doesn't go into detail about the comet until halfway through the book, after providing an introduction to comets and the history of observations of them. Once he gets to the comet, he talks
about its discovery, predictions for its brightness, and how to observe the comet.
Hale's book spends more time on the comet he co-discovered. After a general introduction to comets, hale retells the story if his discovery as well as how Thomas Bopp found the comet. (Bopp did not write a book about the comet, but did contribute prefaces to both Hale's and Hockey's books.) Hale goes into greater details about the prospects for observing the comet, and provides a personal view about the comet and his opinions about the state (the sad state, in his opinion) of science education and employment prospects for astronomers in the U. S.
Those who already know about comets but who are looking for observing guides to the comet will want to turn to Don Machholz's An Observer's Guide to Comet Hale-Bopp. Machholz, a noted comet observer, provides sky charts and information on hot to observe the comet, including tips for using binoculars and telescopes to see the comet in greater detail. While the sky charts might seem like overkill now, as the comet is easily seen even in light-polluted skies, the charts continue into 1998, when the comet will have dimmed but will still be of interest to amateur astronomers.
Of the four books reviewed here, the book that will still be useful long after Hale-Bopp has dimmed from view is Fred Schaaf's Comet of the Century. Schaaf provides a history of "great" comets, comets which became bright enough and/or were visible long enough to make a considerable impression on astronomers and the general public alike. These comets have appeared at irregular times in historical records for over 2,000 years, with some of the greatest visible in the daytime or possessing tails that stretched across a large part of the sky.
Schaaf's book also provides a history of not only Hale-Bopp, but last year's Hyakutake, which also qualifies as a "great comet" as it dazzled observers in the northern hemisphere in late March. The book includes a narrative calendar for Hale-Bopp to guide observers in their observations of the latest comet that is likely to be considered "great."
This leaves open the question: is Hale-Bopp the "Comet of the Century?" Schaaf argues that it's difficult to single out a single comet because of the many complex factors that determine how spectacular a comet appears. However, he argues that if the comet does reach the "mind-boggling" magnitudes of -1 to -2 (the comet is near -1 now), we would be hard-pressed not to consider it, under the relative arbitrary rules of the game, as our "comet of the century."
|